Display ad
HomeEntertainmentMoviesWhy Dune Should Be a Movie Trilogy

Why Dune Should Be a Movie Trilogy

Sometimes the dimensions of a narrative has nothing to do with what number of phrases are used to inform it.

Think of Peter Jackson’s filmmaking experience with the works of J.R.R Tolkien. His ardour to deliver The Lord of the Rings to the display screen had him soliciting and being rejected by practically each main movie studio within the late Nineteen Nineties. Most folks wouldn’t even meet with him, and the few studios that did have been unwilling to speak about making any a couple of movie, aside from Polygram Entertainment and New Line Cinemas. Polygram was within the course of of adjusting palms and will do nothing on the time, which left New Line as Peter Jackson’s final and solely hope.


When Peter Jackson (who was adamantly against making an attempt to inform the story in a single movie) lastly met with Bob Shaye, the pinnacle of New Line, Shaye famously requested him why he was pitching The Lord of the Rings as two movies. Jackson thought one other request to do it multi functional movie was coming, however Shaye stunned him by asking why Jackson was suggesting two movies when there have been three books. Shouldn’t there be three movies? Because of that, The Lord of the Rings films turned a actuality with the prospect to be finished proper.

New Line Cinema

Imagine what The Lord of the Rings story would have been like as a single film. Or even two. In truth, the story in Peter Jackson’s trilogy of movies is greatest advised via the prolonged editions, that are about 4 hours every. If these 12 cumulative hours of story really had been crushed right into a single three-hour film, it’s arduous to think about it turning out as something aside from one other main disappointment for Lord of the Rings followers.

Then think about what occurred with the subsequent work by Tolkien that Peter Jackson delivered to the display screen. Leveraging his success with Lord of the Rings, he took a single guide in The Hobbit and stretched that into three large movies. The Hobbit movie trilogy was appreciated by some, however was typically thought to be lower than what Jackson had achieved with Lord of the Rings, and belaboring the story might need had one thing to do with that consensus. In this occasion, extra movies might have damage the story as an alternative of serving to it.

Dune Is to Science Fiction What Lord of the Rings Is to Fantasy

Warner Bros.

Dune is as revered and instrumental to the science fiction style as The Lord of the Rings is to the high fantasy genre. A piece of towering creativeness by Frank Herbert that was printed in 1965 (the identical yr that Ballantine Books printed a revised version of The Lord of the Rings trilogy in paperback, bringing the story of the One Ring to the plenty), Dune is equal components compelling drama, flawless science fiction, philosophical hypothesis, and political thriller. Other groundbreaking science fiction works like Isaac Asimov’s Foundation sequence and Larry Niven’s Ringworld sequence felt dry and stiff in comparison with the heat and richness of Dune.

Such a robust story looks like it ought to have been taken to the massive display screen shortly after its launch. But the Dune novel takes full benefit of literary methods that make a simple screenplay practically not possible, most notably important quantities of italicized interior monologue that describe a lot of the backstory and lots of the ideas and feelings of the characters. Matching the graceful transitions of expositional and emotional ideas and dialogue of the novel appeared like an not possible activity on movie, particularly for only one movie.

The 1984 Version of Dune

Kyle MacLachlan with blue eyes in Dune
Universal Pictures

Nevertheless, Universal Pictures made the try in 1984, selecting acclaimed director David Lynch to deliver the Dune story to life. Many of people who had by no means learn the Dune novel have been intrigued by the story when seeing it in theaters in 1984, however followers who beloved and appreciated the genius of the novel have been upset with lots of the film’s elements.

To start with, though Dune was a single novel, the 2 hour and seventeen minute working time of the theatrical minimize wasn’t practically lengthy sufficient to do justice to the intricate story. Important scenes needed to be written out, such because the Atreides banquet on Arrakis scene that Frank Herbert felt was of important significance. But he understood the time constraints of movie and supported Lynch’s selections. This was merely a case the place a single novel advised a a lot greater story than a single movie may maintain, so maybe Lynch ought to’ve gone the Jackson route of agreeing solely to a number of movies, quite than one.

Related: Dune: How Far Into Frank Herbert’s Universe Will Villeneuve Go?

Another disappointment was the casting. The Paul Atreides of the novel was not solely a younger teenager, he was a late bloomer. Casting six-foot-tall, 25-year-old Kyle MacLachlan as Paul appeared like a stumble proper out of the gate. And whereas the forged had many different proficient stars, including Patrick Stewart, Linda Hunt, Brad Dourif, and Sting, there by no means gave the impression to be chemistry between the actors or cohesion to the script as they walked via their strains.

One of essentially the most tough ideas of the novel to visualise was “the voice,” an influence of persuasion developed by a political sect and an important gadget utilized by two of the story’s heroic characters. The concept was so daunting and so indispensable, Lynch selected to rewrite this means right into a sonic hand-held weapon that could possibly be manufactured and handed out to any previous good-guy soldier.

All these and lots of extra constraints and modifications dashed the hopes of devoted Dune followers who needed to see their beloved story advised nicely on the display screen. Even director David Lynch has been quoted as saying of his 1984 try at Dune, “It was a failure and I didn’t have the final cut. I’ve told this story a billion times. It’s not the film I wanted to make. I like certain parts of it very much — but it was a total failure for me.”

The 2021 Version of Dune: Part 1

Dave Bautista in Dune (2021)
Warner Bros.

Dune followers upset with the 1984 providing rejoiced when listening to the information that director Denis Villeneuve was going to show his life-long ardour for Dune right into a critical movie mission, a lot as Peter Jackson did along with his life-long ardour for The Lord of the Rings. And like Jackson (and in contrast to Lynch), Villeneuve was adamantly against making an attempt to inform the epic story in only one movie. This appeared like a dream come true for each followers of science fiction and followers of movie generally.

But astoundingly, when Warner Bros. agreed to provide Villeneuve’s adaptation of Dune, the studio solely authorized one movie, regardless of the director’s insistence on the need of extra. Considering what Peter Jackson and New Line did with The Lord of the Rings, this “prove it” mannequin should have been insulting and discouraging for Villeneuve (who had simply scored a hit with Blade Runner: 2049).

Related: Here’s Every Denis Villeneuve Film, Ranked

It can solely be assumed that the management at Warner Bros. was struggling to know deal with the consequences of a worldwide pandemic on theater attendance, in addition to the rising development of audiences shifting from theaters to streaming providers. But it nonetheless appears pathetic {that a} film studio was devoid of the braveness and imaginative and prescient that Bob Shaye and New Line displayed with The Lord of the Rings. Thankfully, Denis Villeneuve had his personal religion within the story, and religion in his personal expertise, in addition to the creative imaginative and prescient to see what Dune could possibly be, and went forward with Dune: Part 1.

Of course, Dune: Part 1 was magnificent, receiving 10 Academy Award nominations, together with Best Picture and Best Adapted Screenplay, and gained six, for Best Sound, Best Original Score, Best Film Editing, Best Production Design, Best Visual Effects, and Best Cinematography. Dune: Part 2 was authorized simply days after Dune: Part 1 opened, and is ready to complete telling the story of the Dune novel in November 2023.

How a Dune: Part 3 Could Be Made

Dune Zendaya
Warner Bros.

Since Dune: Part 1 has “proven itself” in grand trend, and Dune: Part 2 is in manufacturing, Warner Bros. has one more alternative to indicate it may be a daring and brave film studio.

Fans of the Dune novels know that the story of Paul Atreides doesn’t finish with the top of the Dune novel. Frank Herbert’s sequel, Dune Messiah, printed in 1969, follows Paul and Chani into the tough terrain that comes after the climb to the highest. Their sacrifice and willpower to beat the percentages has vaulted them from a struggling renegade House to the rule of an Empire, and their unlikely triumph has made them the most important targets within the universe. And all the ability of the throne can’t maintain Paul from watching his nightmare of crusades in his identify wash the worlds of the Empire in blood.

Related: Jason Momoa Says He Could Return to the Dune Franchise

Dune Messiah is a a lot shorter novel than Dune, maybe the right size to make instantly right into a screenplay for Dune: Part 3. It comes full with new villains and unimaginable plot twists. And one of many advantages of a 3rd movie is that many of the manufacturing issues have already been solved within the first two movies. From nearly each angle, a Dune trilogy of movies makes excellent sense.

How a Dune Trilogy Would Change the Tone of the Story

Warner Bros. 

But the actually compelling cause to make a Dune: Part 3 from Dune Messiah is what it does to the story. One of the great issues about Dune is that it’s a narrative that concludes in a supremely satisfying and constructive method. It’s a narrative of righting wrongs, of overcoming injustice, of the underdog triumphing. After watching Dune: Part 2, audiences are going to go away smiling. They are going to be impressed. They are going to really feel like overcoming their issues and conquering their worlds.

Dune Messiah modifications all that. As the story continues, the viewers learns that holding energy is a unique factor than gaining energy. There are many downsides and troubles that always accompany excessive success. If a Dune: Part 3 will get made out of Dune Messiah, audiences will not be going to be leaving with the identical smiles and inspiration they took from Dune: Part 2. The conclusion will likely be far more somber and considerate. It will likely be extra just like the profound influence of Hamlet or West Side Story than the feel-good endings of most epic hero tales. And that will likely be a better degree of artwork.

After the 1984 film version of Dune, it was so much to ask {that a} world-class director with a deep love for the franchise would come alongside and do for Dune what Peter Jackson did for The Lord of the Rings. It was simply an excessive amount of to hope for. And then, miraculously, one of many movie business’s rising stars, Denis Villeneuve, reveals he has the eagerness wanted to inform the Dune story the best way it needs to be advised. And it seems that he’s, in truth, the right particular person to do it, as involved as essentially the most devoted fan with giving Dune the time it wants, and even enduring a shortsighted studio to make it occur.

Now, followers can solely hope that the miracle gained’t finish with Dune: Part 2, as a result of the story will be even greater and higher with Dune: Part 3.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular