Home Health Medicine Estimated GFR Can Widely Diverge From Measured GFR

Estimated GFR Can Widely Diverge From Measured GFR


An individual’s estimated glomerular filtration price (eGFR), a mainstay for assessing renal operate and well being, can usually considerably differ from that individual’s precise, instantly measured GFR (mGFR), a take a look at carried out far much less usually however which can now warrant a wider function as new proof paperwork simply how divergent mGFR and eGFR could be.

Tariq Shafi, MD

“Clinicians need to recognize that the eGFR is not an mGFR replacement and consider eGFR’s inaccuracy while managing individual patients,” concluded Tariq Shafi, MD, and his co-authors in a examine published online in Annals of Internal Medicine on July 4.

“We hope that this work will motivate making directly measured GFR widely available,” mentioned Shafi, director of the Division of Nephrology on the University of Mississippi Medical Center in Jackson, in an interview.

But different nephrologists say that the restrictions of eGFR measures have been appreciated for years, and that the brand new report ought to have little affect on how evaluation of kidney operate is carried out for the overwhelming majority of US sufferers.

‘Not Something That We Have Not Known’

“This is not describing something that we have not known. The imprecision of an estimated GFR needs to be understood, but for more than 85% of patients,” evaluation of kidney operate by eGFR primarily based on serum creatinine ranges “is more than sufficient,” commented Paul Palevsky, MD, chief of the Renal Section of the VA Pittsburgh Health System and president of the National Kidney Foundation.

For most of the sufferers for whom a creatinine-based eGFR isn’t satisfactory, an eGFR primarily based on blood ranges of cystatin C can usually suffice, Palevsky added in an interview. “For the vast majority of patients” a measured GFR, primarily based on monitoring the renal clearance of an injected bolus of iohexol, “is inconvenient and expensive.”

During his 38 years in observe, “I have never had to order an mGFR,” declared Palevsky, who can also be a professor of drugs on the University of Pittsburgh.

The findings within the new report by Shafi “encourage the message we’ve been saying for a long time, and which are articulated in the chronic kidney disease guidelines [from KDIGO]: eGFR is an estimate and is a very appropriate first-line test for the vast majority of situations,” agreed Lesley A. Inker, MD, director of the Kidney and Blood Pressure Center at Tufts University School of Medicine in Boston.

The new report “confirms that eGFR is an estimate, and clinicians need to be thoughtful about that,” Inker mentioned in an interview.

Shafi and his associates analyzed knowledge from 3223 US adults who had been enrolled in any of 4 potential cohort research that recorded measurements of each their eGFR and mGFR. Their calculations confirmed that whereas the distinction between eGFR and mGFR values was negligible throughout everybody within the examine, the variations could possibly be fairly substantial in anyone particular person individual.

eGFR and mGFR Difference Exceeds 20 mL/min/1.73 m2 in Some People

For instance, amongst individuals who had an eGFR of 60 mL/min/1.73 m2 calculated utilizing present, customary strategies, the vary of mGFRs for 95% of those individuals ranged from a low of 36 mL/min/1.73 m2 to a excessive of 87 mL/min/1.73 m2. This corresponds to a divergence of as a lot as 24 mL/min/1.73 m2 on the low facet, and as a lot as 27 mL/min/1.73 m2 on the excessive facet.

In distinction, for your complete cohort of greater than 3000 individuals the median divergence between eGFR and mGFR was 0.6 mL/min/1.73m2 (with eGFR being the upper worth).

“We are highlighting that reporting eGFR as a single number is incorrect. Many clinicians think that the reported eGFR on the lab report is the same as mGFR, but the distribution of uncertainty needs to be provided as well,” defined Shafi in an interview.

“If we say and believe that GFR is the best index for measuring kidney function, then we must try to make the best way to assess kidney function available to our patients. Directly measuring GFR is the best test to assess GFR, and it should be available for US patients,” harassed Shafi, who can also be a professor of drugs on the University of Mississippi Medical Center.

mGFR Has Logistical Drawbacks

But the truth is that the present strategies for instantly measuring GFR are comparatively costly, cumbersome, and time-consuming and have restricted availability, says Palevsky.

In distinction to measurement of serum creatinine, which normally prices $1 or much less, or cystatin C, which can price just a few {dollars}, direct measurement of GFR primarily based on clearance of an iohexol bolus from the blood prices maybe a few hundred {dollars}, includes drawing a number of blood samples over a time period, and has restricted availability from business US laboratories.

In addition, Palevsky famous that whereas GFR is a crucial metric for assessing an individual’s kidney operate, it ought to by no means be relied on solely to trace development of chronic kidney disease. The stage of an individual’s albuminuria is a key, complementary measure that in lots of circumstances is much more vital than eGFR. Changes in eGFR over time, and an individual’s general scientific historical past and presentation present additional, vital steering on kidney illness severity and trajectory and the suitable course of administration.

The examine acquired no business funding. Shafi and Palevsky had no disclosures. Inker has been a guide to Diametrix and has acquired analysis funding or advisory charges to her establishment from the Chinnocks, Goldfinch, Omeros, Reata, and Tricida.

Ann Intern Med. July 4, 2022. Abstract

Mitchel L. Zoler is a reporter with Medscape and MDedge primarily based within the Philadelphia area. @mitchelzoler

For extra diabetes and endocrinology information, observe us on Twitter and Facebook

Follow Medscape on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here